This is why I cannot stomach science porn: those optimistic science newsletter features. We have a very low bar today for what "understanding" means. As an engineer, I am not confident that I understanding something until I can build it.
Right! Saying "the day-dreamy bit connects to the executive planning bit to make creativity happen" isn't exactly helpful as a building manual for what's going on
> As an engineer, I am not confident that I understanding something until I can build it.
I'm trained as a research scientist but have worked in the engineering industry for 30 years. The great thing about building things is that you don't just learn how systems might work, but how readily they can be made to function differently. So where scientific understanding may still be narrowly predictive, engineering helps explore outside the narrowness.
It's all empiricism, but we've had the engineering side of empiricism for as long as we have had wooden and stone tools, manufactured fibres and cooking -- the science technically came much later.
Very well-written, thanks. I find when most people want to know about "neuroscience" (and I get asked about it a lot as an ex-neuroscience prof) what they really want to know about is psychology with an answer that includes mention of a brain lobe or chemical (e.g., dopamine). Seductive allure of the illusion of mechanistic understanding indeed.
Regarding creativity, for example: The balance of convergent and divergent thinking is really interesting and insightful, but saying that each type lights up this or that ginormous clump of 10s of millions of cells adds nothing but the seductive allure of the etc etc.
I realize I'm late to this article but I just want to share my appreciation! I work as a psychologist and mediocre and misleading neuroscience seems to be everywhere among my peers. I feel it often obfuscates the difficulties we are actually trying to support people with.
In the worst case scenario, pop neuroscience/psychology has convinced people that their mental health is something they are the passive recipients of...which often leads them to feeling stuck and hopeless.
And this sometimes puts me into the position of sounding as though I am arguing against reputable science when I implore them to focus on their feelings in navigating forward.
Even when the neuroscience they have seems to be 'good' -- it's rarely actionable, and therefore not particularly useful in a clinical context.
Great piece! I always have to repeat “This is a course about mind, not brain” over and over when I teach Cognitive Psychology. But, I have drifted into an approach of arguing (also over and over) that our models have to fit the machinery running them… dumb mushy neurons firing or not firing in response to some stimulus. I try to get my students to view the brain as the constrain, not the cause. And, I think the cognition is all the more amazing when you think about it this way!
This is such a great take on neuroscience studies. I feel like we often loose the big picture. And of course we move the knowledge of humanity only in increments. And of course that’s ok. But it is not always the case that it serve the purpose of understanding something to sample it more and more and in many different ways. A really complex big picture question, like creativity, requires and deserves a real complex big picture approach.
I don’t think you can help yourself to anything being a “circuit”. Imagine an alien figuring out what a car’s parts are and do based only on low-spatial-resolution information about the distribution of heat.
Imagining: this circuit open, that one closed—light on 💡, now this one open leads to that one closed—light on💡 and that one… stuck? fuck!… and so forth. Anyone remember doing actual snap-lead circuits, or does this just date me as really old?
Nice article. I think a lot of this can be remedied by being more transparent about the limits of our understanding re: how the brain operates when it comes to specific cognitive, emotional, and behavioural processes. Don't toss out neuroscience commentary, let's just not pretend we know exactly what's happening in the brain.
haven’t finished reading this yet but just wanted to mention William Uttal because I love his books in which he criticized neuroscience theories and especially the obsession with and I wanna say magical thinking (?) around imaging.
Great article! I have a very similar approach to writing and talking about neuroscience - I try to avoid talking about brain regions and neurotransmitters as much as possible. It’s almost never accurate and almost always superfluous, as you say. Thanks for resharing this (and writing it in the first place).
Thank you, what a great reminder of humility as a vital feature of researchers.
I'm new around here, but wished to see more of neuroscience and brain regions with a critical approach.
What drives me crazy the most is ads about "Dopamine addiction". Dopamine seems to me like one of the most misused terms of neuroscience in the genral audience, trying to promote all kinds of services.
This is why I cannot stomach science porn: those optimistic science newsletter features. We have a very low bar today for what "understanding" means. As an engineer, I am not confident that I understanding something until I can build it.
Right! Saying "the day-dreamy bit connects to the executive planning bit to make creativity happen" isn't exactly helpful as a building manual for what's going on
Science porn is excellent! 😂 Good point about what we've come to think 'understanding' entails.
Love the term „science porn“ 😂😂
> As an engineer, I am not confident that I understanding something until I can build it.
I'm trained as a research scientist but have worked in the engineering industry for 30 years. The great thing about building things is that you don't just learn how systems might work, but how readily they can be made to function differently. So where scientific understanding may still be narrowly predictive, engineering helps explore outside the narrowness.
It's all empiricism, but we've had the engineering side of empiricism for as long as we have had wooden and stone tools, manufactured fibres and cooking -- the science technically came much later.
Tommy, you have a talent to clearly articulate ideas that many of us have a difficult time working through. Kudos… truly awesome
Thanks, Mike!
Very well-written, thanks. I find when most people want to know about "neuroscience" (and I get asked about it a lot as an ex-neuroscience prof) what they really want to know about is psychology with an answer that includes mention of a brain lobe or chemical (e.g., dopamine). Seductive allure of the illusion of mechanistic understanding indeed.
Regarding creativity, for example: The balance of convergent and divergent thinking is really interesting and insightful, but saying that each type lights up this or that ginormous clump of 10s of millions of cells adds nothing but the seductive allure of the etc etc.
Exactly, your experience of what people seem to want to hear matches my own. Makes it very easy for superfluous neuro fluff pieces to make the rounds
I realize I'm late to this article but I just want to share my appreciation! I work as a psychologist and mediocre and misleading neuroscience seems to be everywhere among my peers. I feel it often obfuscates the difficulties we are actually trying to support people with.
In the worst case scenario, pop neuroscience/psychology has convinced people that their mental health is something they are the passive recipients of...which often leads them to feeling stuck and hopeless.
And this sometimes puts me into the position of sounding as though I am arguing against reputable science when I implore them to focus on their feelings in navigating forward.
Even when the neuroscience they have seems to be 'good' -- it's rarely actionable, and therefore not particularly useful in a clinical context.
Great piece! I always have to repeat “This is a course about mind, not brain” over and over when I teach Cognitive Psychology. But, I have drifted into an approach of arguing (also over and over) that our models have to fit the machinery running them… dumb mushy neurons firing or not firing in response to some stimulus. I try to get my students to view the brain as the constrain, not the cause. And, I think the cognition is all the more amazing when you think about it this way!
This is such a great take on neuroscience studies. I feel like we often loose the big picture. And of course we move the knowledge of humanity only in increments. And of course that’s ok. But it is not always the case that it serve the purpose of understanding something to sample it more and more and in many different ways. A really complex big picture question, like creativity, requires and deserves a real complex big picture approach.
My dick has been associated with creative tasks
🤔
Association is not causation, Tommy. You can relax
Well I’m a father Mark, but I wasn’t aware that you are too. What did your dick create?
imagine trying to figure out how computers, cars, or typewriters work based only on which parts “light up” and when.
I don’t think you can help yourself to anything being a “circuit”. Imagine an alien figuring out what a car’s parts are and do based only on low-spatial-resolution information about the distribution of heat.
Imagining: this circuit open, that one closed—light on 💡, now this one open leads to that one closed—light on💡 and that one… stuck? fuck!… and so forth. Anyone remember doing actual snap-lead circuits, or does this just date me as really old?
Nice article. I think a lot of this can be remedied by being more transparent about the limits of our understanding re: how the brain operates when it comes to specific cognitive, emotional, and behavioural processes. Don't toss out neuroscience commentary, let's just not pretend we know exactly what's happening in the brain.
haven’t finished reading this yet but just wanted to mention William Uttal because I love his books in which he criticized neuroscience theories and especially the obsession with and I wanna say magical thinking (?) around imaging.
Great piece. The point that you can light up regions in a scanner without actually explaining creativity really lands.
Great article! I have a very similar approach to writing and talking about neuroscience - I try to avoid talking about brain regions and neurotransmitters as much as possible. It’s almost never accurate and almost always superfluous, as you say. Thanks for resharing this (and writing it in the first place).
Thank you for reading and the kind comments!
Thank you, what a great reminder of humility as a vital feature of researchers.
I'm new around here, but wished to see more of neuroscience and brain regions with a critical approach.
What drives me crazy the most is ads about "Dopamine addiction". Dopamine seems to me like one of the most misused terms of neuroscience in the genral audience, trying to promote all kinds of services.
Yeah the dopamine stuff is pretty out of control. I had a guest post on that: https://open.substack.com/pub/cognitivewonderland/p/what-did-dopamine-do-to-deserve-this
dumb jokes and swears ! Keep those coming mate !
Great post!
Thanks!
I think of the brain as ‘the final frontier’.
And I love the phrase ‘science garnish’. Need to watch my own writing for this.